I Tried Every Marie Callenders Frozen Pot Pie And The Winner Tastes Better Than Homemade

5 Min Read

There’s something undeniably comforting about a warm, flaky pot pie, filled with savory goodness and baked to golden perfection.

As a fan of homemade cooking, I’ve always been skeptical of frozen meals, but when it comes to Marie Callender’s frozen pot pies, I couldn’t resist putting them to the test.

With a variety of flavors to choose from, ranging from classic chicken to decadent turkey and stuffing, I embarked on a culinary journey to sample each one and determine which, if any, could stand up to the taste of homemade.

The Contenders

Marie Callender’s offers a diverse selection of frozen pot pies, each boasting its own unique blend of flavors and ingredients.

From the traditional Chicken Pot Pie to the more adventurous flavors like Beef & Bean Chili Pot Pie, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

Here’s a rundown of the contenders:

Chicken Pot Pie: The classic choice, filled with tender chicken, vegetables, and creamy gravy, all nestled beneath a flaky crust.

Turkey Pot Pie: A Thanksgiving-inspired delight, featuring tender chunks of turkey, stuffing, and vegetables, smothered in rich gravy and topped with a golden crust.

Beef Pot Pie: A hearty option, packed with seasoned beef, vegetables, and a savory gravy, all wrapped in a buttery crust.

Turkey & Stuffing: A holiday favorite, combining juicy turkey, savory stuffing, and vegetables in a creamy gravy, topped with a flaky crust.

The Taste Test

Armed with a hungry appetite and a discerning palate, I embarked on my mission to sample each pot pie and determine which one would reign supreme.

Here’s what I discovered:

Chicken Pot Pie

The classic Chicken Pot Pie set a high bar with its tender chunks of chicken, perfectly cooked vegetables, and creamy gravy.

The flaky crust provided a satisfying crunch, while the filling was rich and flavorful.

It was a comforting and familiar taste that reminded me of homemade pot pies enjoyed in childhood.

Turkey Pot Pie

Next up was the Turkey Pot Pie, and I must admit, I was pleasantly surprised.

The tender turkey, savory stuffing, and hearty vegetables created a harmonious blend of flavors that transported me straight to Thanksgiving dinner.

The addition of stuffing added an extra layer of comfort, making this pot pie a standout contender.

Beef Pot Pie

The Beef Pot Pie offered a departure from the poultry-centric options, and it did not disappoint.

The seasoned beef was tender and flavorful, complemented by the rich gravy and perfectly cooked vegetables.

The flaky crust provided the perfect vessel for soaking up the savory juices, making each bite a delight.

Turkey & Stuffing

Last but not least was the Turkey & Stuffing Pot Pie, and it quickly became clear why this flavor is a holiday favorite.

The combination of juicy turkey, savory stuffing, and creamy gravy was reminiscent of a traditional Thanksgiving feast.

Each bite was a comforting reminder of cherished holiday memories.

The Verdict

After careful consideration and more than a few delicious bites, I’m pleased to announce that the winner of the Marie Callender’s Frozen Pot Pie taste test is…

Turkey Pot Pie!

With its perfectly cooked turkey, savory stuffing, and hearty vegetables, the Turkey Pot Pie captured the essence of a homemade holiday meal.

The flavors were balanced and comforting, and the flaky crust provided the perfect finishing touch.

While all of the pot pies were delicious in their own right, the Turkey Pot Pie stood out as the clear winner, proving that sometimes, even frozen meals can rival homemade cooking.

So the next time you’re craving a comforting pot pie but don’t have the time or energy to make it from scratch, don’t hesitate to reach for a Marie Callender’s Frozen Pot Pie. You just might be pleasantly surprised by the deliciousness that awaits!

Share This Article
Leave a comment